The Pantry Club is The Olive Oil Pantry’s membership club, which brings savings every month to its members. Available at three membership levels (Silver, Gold, and Platinum), the Pantry Club provides one, two, or three 250 ml bottles of olive oil or balsamic vinegar (dependent upon membership level) at a discounted price. Gold and Platinum members also receive discounts on additional bottle refills (after refilling their monthly bottle allotment). All Pantry Club members also receive a free reusable bag (capable of holding up to six olive oil/balsamic vinegar bottles), as well as in-store discounts, event discounts, and a free bottle on their birthday.
All of these benefits are available at a fixed monthly cost. The minimum membership length is three months, after which you can cancel at any time. See the table below for a summary of Pantry Club benefits.
| Platinum | Gold | Silver | |
| Monthly Program Price1 | $45.00/month | $30.00/month | $15.00/month |
| Bottles per Month2 | Three (3) 250 ml bottles | Two (2) 250 ml bottles | One (1) 250 ml bottle |
| Bottle Return Discount3 | 10% off refills | 5% off refills | N/A |
| Reusable Shopping Bag | One (1) bag | One (1) bag | One (1) bag |
| In-Store Discount4 | 20% off | 15% off | 10% off |
| Store Events5 | 10% off Earliest registration | 10% off Earlier registration | 10% off Early registration |
| Free Birthday Bottle6 | One (1) 250 ml bottle | One (1) 100 ml bottle | One (1) 60 ml bottle |
1Recurring monthly credit card charge. Prices as of 8/26/2019. Program prices are for standard priced products; specialty products may be substituted by paying the price difference in-store. Subscription can be cancelled by the member at any time after the third monthly billing. Program may be discontinued by The Olive Oil Pantry at any time.
2Program members can receive their monthly bottle allotment on or after their subscription billing date for that month. Bottles may be substituted for other bottle sizes totaling the same overall capacity (e.g., for the Gold membership, one 500 ml bottle may be selected in lieu of two 250 ml bottles). Bottles not received by a program member during a given month are rolled over to the next month – members do not lose their monthly bottle allowance if not collected.
3Bottle return discounts are applied to 250 ml or larger bottles beyond the monthly program bottle allotment which are returned by the member to the store clean and dry, and in good condition (as defined by the Bottle Return Policy) and refilled at standard prices. Bottle return discounts are in addition to any complimentary bottles which may be provided under the Bottle Return Policy. See Bottle Return Policy for details. Bottle Return Policy is subject to change.
4In-store discount applies to regularly priced in-stock gourmet food items, flatware, and beauty products. Discount does not apply to oils/vinegars, prepared foods, online (website) items, shipping/handling fees, gift cards/certificates, program membership fees, or sale/clearance items.
5In addition to 10% discount on the registration fees for in-store events, program members are also notified (and provided the opportunity to register for) in-store events earlier than the general public. Length of advance notification varies by program level.
6Program member receives one free bottle of standard or premium priced bottle of oil or vinegar in the indicated size within two weeks of his/her birthday. Member must provide appropriate state- or federal-issued identification as proof of birthday. Specialty products (e.g., white truffle olive oil) are not available as free birthday bottles.